Shopify Payments vs PayPal: Key Differences, Fees & Best Choice for 2025
Compare Shopify Payments vs PayPal in 2025. Learn about transaction fees, fixed costs, payment gateways, and which option is better for your online store.
This publication is provided for general information purposes and does not constitute legal, tax or other professional advice from Wise US Inc. or its affiliates, and it is not intended as a substitute for obtaining business advice from a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) or tax lawyer. |
---|
If you're a foreign company doing business in the United States through a U.S. branch, there's a unique tax you need to be aware of, which is the Branch Profits Tax (BPT). While corporations typically pay the standard corporate income tax on their U.S. earnings, the BPT adds another layer, specifically targeting foreign corporations.
It’s basically the IRS’s way of making sure that profits from U.S. operations aren’t quietly funneled out of the country without a fair share going to Uncle Sam. Essentially, the tax applies to what’s considered "dividend-equivalent amounts” profits that would have been taxed if the U.S. branch had been a subsidiary paying dividends.1
So let’s take a look at what branch profit taxes are in the U.S. and how they work, so you can better understand your requirements as a business owner.
Managing international business payments?
Try Wise Business ->
Table of contents |
---|
If a foreign company does business in the U.S. through a branch rather than a subsidiary, it might face something called the Branch Profits Tax. Think of it like this: when a U.S. subsidiary pays dividends to its foreign parent, there's usually a withholding tax. The BPT is the IRS’s way of applying a similar tax to profits from a U.S. branch, even though no dividends are paid.1
Here’s how it works: after the foreign company pays regular U.S. income tax on its effectively connected income (ECI), the remaining profit, the "dividend equivalent amount," can be taxed again at a 30% rate (or less, if a tax treaty applies).2 This discourages companies from using branches to avoid withholding taxes.
So with that being said, the U.S. treats branches somewhat like subsidiaries for tax purposes, just to make sure profits leaving the U.S. don’t slip through untaxed.
Branch profits tax is a bit different from regular corporate tax. Regular corporate tax applies to all U.S. corporations on their profits, pretty straightforward. But when a foreign company operates a U.S. branch instead of setting up a separate U.S. subsidiary, things get more complicated. The branch still pays regular corporate tax on its income, but then the IRS adds an extra layer: the branch profits tax.
Why? Because if the company had a U.S. subsidiary, any money sent back to the parent would be taxed as a dividend. So, the branch profits tax is the IRS’s way of making sure that foreign branches don’t get around that second layer of tax.
The branch profits tax was introduced to close a tax loophole. Before it existed, foreign companies could operate in the U.S. through a branch instead of setting up a U.S. subsidiary, and avoid paying certain taxes that American companies or foreign subsidiaries had to pay. Basically, they were able to pull profits out of the U.S. without getting hit with the usual dividend tax.1
The IRS saw this as unfair and created the branch profits tax to level the playing field. Now, even if a foreign company uses a branch, it still pays tax on profits as if it were sending a dividend to its parent company. It helps make sure everyone is taxed equally, no matter the structure.
The “dividend equivalent amount” is a fancy tax term, but it’s actually pretty straightforward once you break it down. When a foreign company operates in the U.S. through a branch (instead of setting up a separate U.S. corporation), the IRS still wants to tax what it thinks would’ve been sent back to the foreign parent company, like a dividend.
That’s where this term comes into play. It’s the amount of U.S. earnings the IRS figures would’ve been distributed if the branch were a subsidiary. That number becomes the basis for the branch profits tax. So even if no money is actually sent home, you could still owe tax on this “as-if” distribution.3
Not necessarily. Whether a company branch is subject to profits tax depends on a few factors. In general, if the branch is earning income from business activities carried out in a particular country (like Hong Kong, for example), it may be subject to that country’s profits tax. The most important factor here is where the profits are derived from. If a branch operates locally and earns income from that location, it’s usually liable. But if the branch doesn’t actually conduct business or generate profits in that country, then it might not be taxed there.
Also, tax treaties between countries can influence this; some may offer relief to avoid double taxation. So, it really comes down to where the income is generated and whether the branch is seen as having a permanent presence for tax purposes.2
When we talk about “branches” for U.S. tax purposes, we’re really referring to a part of a foreign company that’s doing business directly in the U.S. but not set up as a separate U.S. corporation. So, if a foreign company opens an office, factory, or even just has employees working regularly in the U.S., that could be considered a U.S. branch.
The IRS examines whether the foreign company has a “permanent establishment” in the United States. If it does, then the branch profits tax might apply. So yes, you can be a “branch” without even realizing it, and that’s why it’s important to understand how this works.
Just having a U.S. office doesn’t automatically mean you’re hit with the branch profits tax, but it can definitely be a step in that direction. The most important factor here is whether your business has a “U.S. trade or business” and generates effectively connected income (ECI).
If that’s the case, then the IRS may treat your U.S. operations as a branch of your foreign company, which could trigger the branch profits tax. So, while simply opening an office won’t always do it, what you do through that office matters 1
Yes, there are exceptions. Here’s a look at the most common exceptions to branch profit tax:
To claim a treaty benefit for the branch profits tax, you’ll need to provide the right documentation to the IRS. The most important form is IRS Form 8833 (Treaty-Based Return Position Disclosure), which tells the IRS exactly which treaty you’re relying on and which article applies.
You’ll usually file it along with Form 1120-F, which is the U.S. tax return for foreign corporations. You also need to make sure you’re properly documenting residency in the treaty country. Missing any of this could mean you lose the treaty benefit and end up paying the full 30% tax.1
If a foreign corporation does business in the U.S. through a branch rather than a subsidiary, it might be subject to the branch profits tax. So what’s the rate? It’s 30%, but here’s the catch: that’s 30% on the “dividend equivalent amount.” Think of that as the money the IRS assumes the branch would’ve sent home to its foreign parent if it were a subsidiary paying a dividend. The idea is to level the playing field between branches and subsidiaries, so branches don’t get a tax advantage.2
Now, some good news: this 30% rate can be reduced or even eliminated if there’s an applicable tax treaty between the U.S. and the branch’s home country. Many treaties bring it down to 5%, 10%, or even 0%.3
The branch profits tax is tied directly to your U.S. business activity. It’s calculated annually based on the “dividend equivalent amount”, which is the U.S. branch’s earnings after regular corporate income tax, minus any reinvested amounts or prior year adjustments. You calculate and report this on Form 1120-F, the U.S. income tax return for foreign corporations.
It’s generally due on the same timeline as regular corporate returns—April 15th for calendar-year filers, with extensions available. Missing it can mean penalties or interest.2
The branch profits tax in the U.S. is designed to make sure foreign companies doing business here through a branch don’t get an unfair tax advantage over those using a U.S. subsidiary. The most important thing here is keeping good records and understanding how your U.S. operations are structured. If you’re a foreign business owner, it’s definitely something to be aware of, especially when planning how to move profits around. At the end of the day, understanding the branch profits tax can save you from unexpected costs and headaches later on.
Wise Business can help you save big time on international payments.
Wise is not a bank, but a Money Services Business (MSB) provider and a smart alternative to banks. The Wise Business account is designed with international business in mind, and makes it easy to send, hold, and manage business funds in currencies.
Signing up to Wise Business allows access to BatchTransfer which you can use to pay up to 1000 invoices in one go. This is perfect for small businesses that are managing a global team, saving a ton of time and hassle when making payments.
Some key features of Wise Business include:
Mid-market rate: Get the mid-market exchange rate with no hidden fees on international transfers
Global Account: Send money to countries and hold multiple currencies, all in one place. You can also get major currency account details for a one-off fee to receive overseas payments like a local
Access to BatchTransfer: Pay up to 1000 invoices in one click. Save time, money, and stress when you make 1000 payments in one click with BatchTransfer payments. Access to BatchTransfer is free with a Wise Business account
Auto-conversions: Don't like the current currency exchange rate? Set your desired rate, and Wise sends the transfer the moment the rate is met
Free invoicing tool: Generate and send professional invoices
No minimum balance requirements or monthly fees: US-based businesses can open an account for free. Learn more about fees here
Sources:
*Please see terms of use and product availability for your region or visit Wise fees and pricing for the most up to date pricing and fee information.
This publication is provided for general information purposes and does not constitute legal, tax or other professional advice from Wise Payments Limited or its subsidiaries and its affiliates, and it is not intended as a substitute for obtaining advice from a financial advisor or any other professional.
We make no representations, warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, that the content in the publication is accurate, complete or up to date.
Compare Shopify Payments vs PayPal in 2025. Learn about transaction fees, fixed costs, payment gateways, and which option is better for your online store.
Discover the key differences, repayment terms and benefits to help you choose the best business funding option between paypal business loan and working capital
Looking for quick financing? Read our 2025 PayPal Business Loan review to explore eligibility, fees, repayment terms, and whether it’s right for your business.
Read our 2025 PayPal Business Credit Card review to learn about cashback perks, no annual fee, and how to apply in minutes.
Read our 2025 PayPal Working Capital review to learn how it works, who qualifies, and whether it’s right for your business.
Company formation in Hungary offers access to the EU market, low taxes, and residency options. Learn about the steps, costs, and compliance rules.