CFO vs. Controller: Who Do You Hire First?

There’s a moment in every founder’s journey when you realize you’ve become the Chief Bottleneck Officer. You’re caught trying to decipher international bank fees instead of planning your next product launch.

This isn’t a sign of failure, but the opposite. You’ve successfully navigated to the edge of the “Complexity Chasm,” where your company’s operational drag now threatens to stifle its growth.

And with businesses losing up to 5% on international transactions,¹ you can’t afford to stay stuck as a result of this hidden tax on your success. This guide offers a clear diagnostic to help you hire the right financial leader to get you across.

We'll also discuss the Wise Business account. The global account that can help your company with all things cross-border.

Do you send and receive global payments?

Try Wise Business >>

Wise Trustpilot Score: 4.3 stars on 230,000+ reviews
No minimum balance requirement and no monthly fees
Integrates with QuickBooks, Xero, Sage, and more

Deciding Whether You Need a CFO or Controller

Before you dive into job descriptions and salary benchmarks, you need a diagnosis. The entire complex decision of whether to hire a Financial Controller or a Chief Financial Officer (CFO) can be distilled into one powerful question.

Ask yourself honestly: Is your most pressing financial problem the accuracy of the past or the uncertainty of the future? Your answer points directly to your next hire.

The Controller Role

You have an accuracy-of-the-past problem if you find yourself wrestling with messy books and late reports. If you’re bogged down by operational chaos — unreconciled payments, confusing international fees, a nagging fear about tax compliance — your foundation is shaky.

You’re trying to drive forward while looking through a foggy rear view mirror, and you need a Controller.

The CFO Role

You have an uncertainty-of-the-future problem if your books are clean, but you still feel like you’re flying blind. If you can’t confidently forecast your cash runway, model future scenarios, or lack a compelling financial story for your investors, you are navigating without a map. This signals a need for a CFO.

This question not only gives you a job title, but also reveals the fundamental weakness in your company's current stage. One problem requires an architect of systems, while the other requires an architect of strategy.

The Controller: Architect of Your Financial Operating System

It’s a painful irony that the more your company grows, the more your time seems to shrink. If you or your finance department are spending up to 15 hours a week just wrestling with manual payment processes, you are losing time and throttling your own growth.

This is the chaos a great Controller is hired to conquer. They manage finances and provide an accurate picture of your company’s financial health, all while building its financial engine from the ground up.

Guardian of Accuracy and Rules

At a foundational level, the Controller is the master of process and the guardian of your company’s financial integrity. This is the person who owns the relentless rhythm of the financial close, ensuring your P&L, balance sheet and cash flow statements are delivered on time and without error.

They are deeply versed in the rules of the road, like Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), and act as your first line of defense against compliance missteps. A great Controller builds the internal controls that safeguard your assets from fraud and costly mistakes.

Making Your Finance Tools Talk to Each Other

A modern Controller’s role has evolved into a tech-savvy architect² who builds your company’s integrated finance stack as they understand that true efficiency comes from making systems talk to each other.

They are the ones who ensure your global financial hub, like Wise, syncs flawlessly through its API with your accounting software. This creates a single source of truth and eliminates the soul-crushing task of manual reconciliation.

These automated workflows mean an employee expense payment in Lisbon is instantly categorized and synced, killing the traditional reporting nightmare before it even begins.

Making Global Payments Faster and Cheaper

The technical expertise of a Controller extends to the very mechanics of how your money moves. A truly great Controller manages your Payment Operations (PayOps) with a strategist’s eye, performing payment rail analysis to understand why a local network can turn a three-day, $25 wire transfer into a same-day, sub-dollar transaction.

They manage your multi-currency treasury, ensuring the revenue you earn in Euros isn’t needlessly converted or left “trapped” when you need to pay suppliers in Pounds.

They also conduct a rigorous cost-per-transaction analysis, uncovering the hidden FX markups and intermediary bank fees that erode your profits. This transforms your financial operations from a reactive cost center into a lean, efficient and global-ready engine.

The CFO: Architect of Strategic Value and Growth

Once your financial engine is running smoothly, the conversation must change. It evolves from tracking what you’ve spent to strategically directing where you will go.

This is the domain of the Chief Financial Officer. It’s why, according to a Deloitte survey,³ a majority of CEOs now see their CFO not as a senior accountant, but as a key hiring partner in driving the entire business forward. They are hired to architect your company’s future value.

Building Your Financial Roadmap

A CFO’s primary role is to create the company’s long-term financial strategy: a living, breathing model that translates your vision into numbers. They go beyond simple forecasting to conduct rigorous scenario financial planning, answering the critical questions that keep founders awake at night: What happens to our cash runway if a major client leaves? How does doubling our marketing spend affect our profitability timeline?

CFOs provide the data-driven insights that allow you and your board to make decisions with confidence, not just gut instinct.

Protecting Your Profits from Currency Swings

For any business operating across borders, one of the biggest unseen risks is foreign exchange (FX) volatility. A CFO is your expert guide in managing this threat.

If you generate revenue in Euros but most of your costs are in U.S. Dollars, a drop in the Euro's value can shrink your profit margin overnight. A CFO proactively manages this exposure.

They might implement a “natural hedge” by using a multi-currency account to hold onto your foreign revenue. This allows you to pay international expenses directly from those funds without being forced into costly, ill-timed conversions, protecting the real value of the money you earn.

Investing Your Money Where It Matters Most

While a Controller manages a budget, which is essentially permission to spend, a CFO leads capital allocation, which is the art of investing for the highest possible return.

Their central question is always, "Where should the next dollar of capital go?" Should it be invested in marketing to lower your acquisition cost, or in engineering to reduce churn? They analyze the unit economics behind every major decision, ensuring your resources are deployed with discipline.

This expertise transforms your financial function from a reporting necessity into a powerful driver of strategic growth, especially when leading fundraising rounds and telling your company’s financial story to the world.

Send Fast and Secure International Business Payments - See Rates Below

What Time to Hire a CFO or Controller

The decision of who to hire, and when, shouldn’t be based on revenue alone. The most reliable triggers are your own pain points, which almost always scale in tandem with your global ambition.

Red Flags that Signal You Need a Controller

You are feeling the need for a Controller when your operational complexity is starting to cause friction and risk. The first sign is when you begin paying international contractors or suppliers, and your simple domestic payment system becomes a bottleneck of slow transfers and messy reconciliation.

You’ll find your finance lead spending more time hunting down payments than analyzing performance. You have no real-time visibility into your cash position across different currency accounts, making you feel out of control.

The need becomes urgent when you must produce GAAP-compliant financial statements for partners, lenders or early-stage investors who demand a higher level of financial rigor.

Triggers that Mean It’s Time for a CFO

The need for a CFO is less about day-to-day pain and more about future opportunity and strategic risk. The clearest trigger is when you are preparing for a priced equity round, like a Seed or Series A. Investors at this stage demand a credible, forward-looking financial model.

Another trigger is a planned expansion into a new country, which requires a strategic plan for everything from entity structure to tax implications.

You’ll also feel the need for a CFO when you realize currency fluctuations are materially impacting your profit margins. The moment your board starts asking complex “what if” questions that you can’t model or answer confidently, it’s time to bring in a CFO.

Your Blueprint for Financial Leadership

Ultimately, the “CFO vs. Controller” question is about sequencing, not about choosing one over the other. The Controller is the architect who builds the rock-solid foundation of accurate data and efficient operations. The CFO uses that foundation to architect the future.

Neglecting either role creates risk. With a staggering percentage of small business failures linked to poor cash flow management,⁴ investing in the right financial expertise at the right time is the most critical decision you can make for sustainable international growth.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Company Have a Controller Without a CFO?

Absolutely. This is the most common path for growing companies. In this setup, the Controller typically reports directly to you as the CEO and focuses entirely on building the financial infrastructure, ensuring accuracy and managing day-to-day operations.

Is it Common for a Controller to be Promoted to a CFO?

Yes, it’s a natural and frequent career progression. For a Controller to succeed in a CFO role, they must evolve beyond their deep technical accounting expertise. The transition requires them to develop broader strategic thinking, strong external communication skills and the leadership capacity to guide the entire business.

What are the Key Qualifications for a Controller and CFO?

You should look for different core competencies. A great Controller almost always has a strong accounting background, often a CPA, and thrives on detail, process and technical accuracy.

A great CFO, on the other hand, may come from a wider range of backgrounds, including finance or business management. Their key skills are strategic leadership, powerful communication and the ability to translate data into a compelling vision for the future.

Should I Hire a Fractional or Full-Time Controller/CFO?

For a scaling company, fractional hiring is a powerful strategy. It allows you to access senior-level expertise without committing to a full-time executive salary.

A fractional Controller can be invaluable for setting up your core systems. Similarly, a fractional CFO can provide the critical strategic guidance needed to navigate a funding round. As your company’s complexity grows, these roles will naturally demand a full-time commitment.

Save Time and Hassle With Wise Business

Wise is not a bank, but a Money Services Business (MSB) provider and a smart alternative to banks. Wise makes it easy to send, hold, and manage business funds in currencies. You can get major currency account details for a one-off fee to receive overseas payments like a local. Simply add the local account details when billing international customers to receive international payments with no fees.

Account opening is 100% online, with no need to visit a branch or book appointments.

Once you’re set up, you can connect to software such as Wave, FreshBooks, and more. You can also withdraw funds from Stripe without currency conversion fees.

Open a Wise Business account online

Some key benefits of Wise Business include:

Major local account details to receive international payments with ease No monthly account fees just a simple one-off fee for account details Receive payments from e-commerce platforms such as Amazon or via Stripe. Free invoicing tool to generate and send invoices. Create invoices using the Wise invoice generator or invoice templates. Accounting integrations, including a QuickBooks Bill Pay connection. Bill payments will be synced, matched, and categorized in QuickBooks for simple reconciliation. Access to BatchTransfer. Fast payment of up to 1,000 people.

---

Sources:

1. Cross Border Payments in Numbers - FFnews.com
2. What’s Important to The Controller in 2025 - PWC
3. CFOs Signal Bigger Hiring Role - CFO Dive
4. Why Small Businesses Fail - US Chamber